« Winners of Manchester Blog Awards | Main | Don't get stuck in the middle »

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Your observations on 'The Leader's Blog'are perfectly valid, up to a point. I think 'political blogs' whether run by politicians or activists, should have comments and permalinks enabled. But you go too far in declaring the site not a 'real' blog. I've had this discussion over and over in other places (particularly with Tim Ireland) so I won't rehash it here, except to say that the definition of a blog was laid down many years ago and persists in all major blog awards. It does not include RSS feeds, trackback, comments, blogrolls, email links or social bookmarking tools. These are things that have been added to blogs as they developed and are seen by many to enhance blogs and make them more effective and more interesting.

'The Leaders Blog' is still a blog, it just isn't as effective or interesting as it could be.

If I were one of the early bloggers like Kottke, Barger (who coined the term weblog) Drudge, or other leading bloggers like Reynolds, Dooce, Geras or Sullivan (to name just a few) who do not have comments enabled I'd be getting pretty cheesed off at being told I wasn't running a 'proper blog', especially given the fact that some of them were blogging before many of the critics had heard of the word 'blog'.

Hi Mike, many thanks for the comment and as you highlight each to their own.

But I do think the comment facility on blogs is a very valuable resource which can be used to help readers as much as the articles they are attached to.

As I stress to others though, blogging software is just a publishing tool, how it is used and what it hopes to achieve can be as diverse as all the sites out there.

All the best, Craig

The tokenist pseudo blog is a disease of the higher echelons it seems. Consider this one for a lack of activity

http://marketingmanchester.typepad.co.uk/marketing_manchester/

I made a comment maybe a week ago. Perhaps it was dismissed as spammy but I don't see a lot of commenting going on either way.

The comments to this entry are closed.